Dear Editor@Matzav,
With the upcoming Adirei Hatorah event this Sunday, I believe it is essential to discuss a matter that concerns the etiquette, hashkafah and atmosphere of such gatherings.
In recent years, I have noticed a growing trend at various Torah events where people have started clapping after speeches to express their appreciation or admiration.
This has to stop.
I would like to draw attention to the inappropriateness of this gesture at a Torah gathering of gedolim and bnei Torah, such as the one we are eagerly anticipating this Sunday.
Our gedolim and roshei yeshivos who address us at such events are not mere speakers. They are revered sources of Torah wisdom, knowledge, and guidance. I am reminded of the words of Rav Elchonon Wasserman in Kovetz Maamarim Cheilek Alef, where he openly discusses the distinction between our Torah events and “others.” He highlights that at our gatherings, we refrain from the clapping of hands – mechias kapayim – as it detracts from the solemnity and reverence that we strive to uphold.
Clapping is an expression commonly associated with joyous celebrations, sporting events, and other occasions where it is acceptable to applaud and acknowledge accomplishments or achievements.
It has no place at a maamad of kavod haTorah.
I never quite understood why there is clapping at the Siyum Hashas, but we can discuss that at a different time.
It is crucial that we create an avira (environment) that fosters a sense of awe and reverence, true kavod haTorah. Clapping takes away from that.
Please spread the word: Do not clap at the Adirei HaTorah event! It is not a baseball game!
I kindly urge attendees of the Adirei Hatorah event to join me in embracing this important detail. I sincerely hope that this letter will lead to a deeper appreciation of the nature of these events.
Yours sincerely,
A Ben Torah Who Doesn’t Clap